Season 16
16 episodes · 2025
1Secrets of the Sliding Door
A beloved Staten Island teacher is found dead in the home she shared with her husband; an unknown number in her cell phone leads investigators to ultimately unearth her killer.
2Bethany Vanished
When a young pregnant mother goes missing in Virginia, her family embarks on a search, but the case goes cold. Years later, investigators find a woman who may hold the key to solving the case.
3Secrets in Silver Lakes
A young father's murder at work leads investigators to deep secrets about sex, friendship, religion and family.
4The Bad Man
Nearly 40 years after young wife and mother Cathy Krauseneck is found murdered with an axe in her upstate New York home, a new team of investigators joins the cold case to uncover the killer.
5Finding Rita
When a Colorado mother vanishes, the detective discovers a connection to a previous assault.
6The Undoing
Detectives search for answers after Annastasia Hester is stabbed to death in Portland, Oregon.
7The Figure in the House
The wife of a college professor and heir of an oil empire is found murdered in her home.
8A Deal With the Devil
A serial killer murders several people while working as a confidential informant for the FBI.
9Behind Door 813
Twenty seven-year-old Jonathan Crews dies mysteriously in his Texas apartment.
10Who Killed Courtney Coco?
The discovery of a young woman's body in rural Texas sparks a long, multi-state investigation.
11Who Killed Mindy Morgenstern?
A quiet North Dakota college town is left in fear after student Mindy Morgenstern is found dead.
12The Case of the Man with No Name
The investigation into the mysterious disappearance of a Canadian man sparks an international manhunt for an elusive killer with multiple...
13The Charleston Affair
A week before a banker's divorce reaches a settlement, an ex-con says he was hired for murder.
14Hit List
Chilling details come to light in an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting a former NYC police officer's husband. The officer's...
15The Woman At the Bar
A massive manhunt ensues after Lois Riess murders her husband in Minnesota and flees to Florida, where she kills and steals the identity...
16Return to the Lake
Decades after Susan Smith confessed to drowning her two small sons in South Carolina, she advocates for parole. Her ex-husband speaks out...
