Solving murders inside the Amish community is unlike solving any other kind of criminal case. These closed communities are pious, principled and notoriously distrustful of the outside world. Murder in Amish Country uncovers some of the most heinous crimes committed by seemingly moral subjects, and reveals that what happens in the dark... eventually comes to light.
Where to WatchAll options
Stream
Free
Buy
Availability data from JustWatch
- Status
- Ended
- Production
- Our House Media
Keywords
- distrust
- homicide
- amish
- murder
- true crime
- murder investigation
- homicide investigation
- murder victim
- closed society
- amish country
- amish community
Links
Top Cast
Hilary Wirachowsky as Abe's Wife
Rebecca England as Investigator
Seasons
Photos
Reviews
Loading reviews…
More Like This
Worst Neighbor Ever
01 Jul 2026
Trust Me: The False Prophet
08 Apr 2026
The Idaho Murders: College Nightmare
29 Jul 2026
Inside the World's Toughest Prisons
20 Apr 2016
Dateline
31 Mar 1992
Dirty Money
26 Jan 2018
Evil Lives Here
17 Jan 2016
I AM A KILLER
29 May 2018
Death of the Pastor's Wife
26 Aug 2026
Drugs, Inc.
11 Jul 2010
Cold Justice
03 Sep 2013
The Murders at Starved Rock
14 Dec 2021
Homicide Hunter: Lt Joe Kenda
25 Oct 2011
The Yogurt Shop Murders
03 Aug 2025
See No Evil
17 Feb 2015
Cold Case Files
27 Feb 2017
Web of Lies
08 Jan 2014
Homicide
20 Mar 2024
Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes
07 Oct 2022
The Jinx
08 Feb 2015